Introduction: A Tale of Two Worlds
In the vast ocean of contemporary romance novels, Tessa Bailey's "It Happened One Summer" emerges as a beacon, promising readers a journey from the glittering shores of Hollywood to the rugged coastline of a small fishing town in Washington. But does this fish-out-of-water tale manage to reel in hearts, or does it flounder in choppy waters? Let's cast our net and see what we catch in this deep dive review.
The Premise: Instagram Influencer Meets Gruff Sea
Captain
At its core, "It Happened One Summer" is a classic opposites-attract romance with a modern twist. Piper Bellinger, our protagonist, is a socialite and Instagram influencer whose life revolves around parties, fashion, and maintaining her image. When a wild night lands her in jail, her stepfather decides it's time for a reality check. His solution? Sending Piper and her sister Hannah to manage their late father's dive bar in Westport, Washington, for three months.
Enter Brendan Taggart, a local sea captain who's as steady as the tides and about as welcoming as a storm-tossed sea. He's convinced Piper won't last a week in Westport. But as Piper digs her stilettos into small-town life and Brendan's gruff exterior begins to crack, both characters find themselves navigating unexpected waters.
Character Deep Dive: More Than Meets the Eye?
Piper Bellinger: Depth Behind the Designer Sunglasses?
Piper starts as a character that many readers might find difficult to like. She's shallow, privileged, and seemingly vapid. However, Bailey takes us on a journey with Piper, peeling back the layers to reveal a woman who's more complex than her Instagram feed suggests.
As Piper grapples with running a business, connecting with her roots, and discovering her own capabilities, we see glimpses of the person she could be. Her growth, while not always consistent, provides some of the book's most satisfying moments. The question is: does her transformation feel authentic, or does it skim the surface?
Brendan Taggart: The Salty Sea Captain with a Heart of Gold
Brendan is initially presented as the stereotypical gruff, small-town hero. He's a widower, dedicated to his work, and skeptical of city folk. Yet, as the story progresses, we see more nuance to his character. His dedication to his community, his struggle with moving on after loss, and his gradual opening up to Piper add depth to what could have been a one-dimensional character.
However, some readers might find Brendan's quick transition from mourning widower to head-over-heels in love a bit jarring. The question lingers: is his character development organic, or does it feel rushed for the sake of the romance?
The Romance: Sparks Fly or Damp Squib?
The central romance between Piper and Brendan is where opinions seem to diverge most sharply among readers. On one hand, their opposites-attract dynamic provides plenty of entertaining moments and steamy encounters. Bailey is known for her ability to write sizzling scenes, and "It Happened One Summer" doesn't disappoint in that department.
However, the speed at which their relationship develops has raised eyebrows. From barely tolerating each other to professing love in a matter of weeks, some readers might find the progression unrealistic. The lack of substantial conversations between the couple outside of their physical encounters also leaves questions about the depth of their connection.
That said, for readers who enjoy a whirlwind romance and don't mind suspending disbelief, Piper and Brendan's story might just hit the spot.
Themes: More Than Just a Love Story?
While romance is at the forefront, "It Happened One Summer" touches on several deeper themes:
Finding One's Identity: Piper's journey of self-discovery forms the backbone of the story.
Community and Belonging: The contrast between LA's superficial social scene and Westport's tight-knit community is a recurring theme.
Family and Legacy: Piper and Hannah's exploration of their father's past adds emotional depth to the narrative.
Grief and Moving On: Brendan's struggle with his past loss provides a poignant subplot.
The exploration of these themes adds layers to what could have been a simple romantic comedy, though some readers might wish for even deeper dives into these areas.
Writing Style: Smooth Sailing or Choppy Waters?
Tessa Bailey's writing style in "It Happened One Summer" is generally engaging and easy to read. Her dialogue, in particular, shines, with witty banter between characters providing many of the book's highlights.
However, some readers have noted issues with pacing, particularly in the middle sections of the book. The plot can feel scattered at times, with subplots that don't always feel necessary to the main story.
Bailey's descriptive prose brings both the glamour of LA and the charm of Westport to life, though at times, the contrasts between the two settings can feel a bit heavy-handed.
Supporting Cast: Anchors or Dead Weight?
While Piper and Brendan take center stage, the supporting characters add color and depth to the story. Hannah, Piper's sister, stands out as a particularly intriguing character, her loyalty and level-headedness providing a nice contrast to Piper's initial flightiness.
The townsfolk of Westport, from Brendan's crew to the regulars at the bar, help create a sense of community that's crucial to the story's charm. However, some readers might find that certain side characters, particularly those from Piper's LA life, veer into caricature territory.
The Verdict: Summer Fling or Lasting Love?
"It Happened One Summer" is a book that seems to divide opinion. For some readers, it's a delightful escape, a fun and steamy romance with just enough depth to keep things interesting. For others, the rapid character transformations, pacing issues, and occasionally shallow exploration of deeper themes leave something to be desired.
Ultimately, your enjoyment of this book may depend on what you're looking for. If you're in the market for a light, sexy summer read with a fish-out-of-water premise and don't mind suspending disbelief for the sake of romance, "It Happened One Summer" might just be your perfect beach companion.
However, if you're seeking a romance with more gradual character development, deeper explorations of its themes, or a more realistic portrayal of relationship progression, you might find this book leaves you wanting more.
Conclusion: To Read or Not to Read?
"It Happened One Summer is like a summer fling – fun, steamy, and perhaps not meant to be taken too seriously. While it may not be a literary masterpiece, it offers entertainment, escapism, and a few genuine moments of character growth.
Tessa Bailey has crafted a story that, despite its flaws, has clearly resonated with many readers. Whether it will resonate with you depends on your tastes and expectations. If you're willing to dive in with an open mind, you might just find yourself swept away by this tale of love between a socialite and a sea captain.
So, grab your sunscreen, find a cozy spot by the water (or pretend you're by the water), and give "It Happened One Summer" a try. Who knows? You might just find your next favorite beach read.
Additional Reading and Resources
More Book Reviews from That Love Podcast
If you enjoyed this review, check out our takes on other fantastic reads:
All the Little Raindrops by Mia Sheridan: A Harrowing Journey Through Trauma and Resilience
The Backtrack by Erin La Rosa: A Nostalgic Journey Through Time, Love, and Self-Discovery
The Ex Vows by Jessica Joyce: A Vintage Blend of Love, Friendship, and Second Chances
The Au Pair Affair by Tessa Bailey: A Heartwarming Hockey Romance That Scores Big
Romance Community Resources
For more romance novel reviews, discussions, and recommendations, check out these fantastic resources:
Dear Author - A trusted source for honest and well-thought-out reviews, often featuring witty commentary.
All About Romance - One of the oldest romance review sites, offering extensive reviews, author interviews, and discussions covering various romance genres.
Smart Bitches, Trashy Books - Known for its humorous and insightful reviews, this site also features a podcast and community discussions about romance novels.
Heroes and Heartbreakers - This site provides reviews and recommendations, highlighting both popular and lesser-known romance novels.
Romance.io - A site with a comprehensive database of romance novels, offering user-generated reviews and recommendations across various subgenres.
We hope these additional resources enhance your romance reading experience and help you discover your next favorite book!
FAQ: Your Burning Questions Answered
Q: Is "It Happened One Summer" part of a series? A: Yes, it's the first book in the Bellinger Sisters series. The second book, "Hook, Line, and Sinker," focuses on Hannah's story.
Q: How steamy is this book on a scale of 1 to 10? A: Most readers rate it around 7-8. It contains explicit scenes but balances them with plot and character development.
Q: Do I need to know anything about fishing or small-town life to enjoy this book? A: Not at all! The author provides enough context for readers unfamiliar with these aspects to follow along easily.
Q: Are there any trigger warnings for this book? A: The book touches on themes of grief and loss, particularly related to Brendan's backstory. There are also some references to body image issues.
Q: How does this book compare to other Tessa Bailey novels? A: Fans of Bailey's other works will recognize her signature steamy scenes and witty dialogue, though some feel this book has a slightly different tone from her previous works.
Q: Is the ending satisfying? A: Without spoiling anything, the book provides a resolution that most romance readers will find satisfying, though some have criticized it for feeling rushed.
Q: How long is the book? A: The print version is approximately 400 pages, making it a substantial but not overly long read.
Q: Is this book appropriate for young adult readers? A: Due to explicit content, it's generally recommended for adult readers or very mature young adults.
Q: Does the book accurately portray life in a small fishing town? A: While the author creates a charming small-town atmosphere, some readers familiar with actual fishing towns have noted that certain aspects feel romanticized or simplified.
Q: If I enjoy "It Happened One Summer," what other books might I like? A: Fans of this book might enjoy other small-town romances like those by Sally Thorne or Emily Henry's "Beach Read."
Comments