9 Kitchen Trends to Avoid, According to Real Estate Agents
- Joao Nsita
- 2 days ago
- 7 min read
Kitchens are the heart of the home—and a major selling point for buyers. But not every trendy upgrade boosts your property’s value or appeal. Real estate agents, who see countless homes and hear buyer feedback daily, have a keen eye for what works and what flops in the market. In 2025, as design preferences evolve, some once-popular kitchen trends are falling out of favor, potentially turning off prospective buyers or dating your space.
From overdone aesthetics to impractical layouts, these nine kitchen trends are ones agents advise steering clear of if you want to keep your home competitive. Whether you’re renovating for yourself or prepping to sell, here’s what to avoid—and smarter alternatives to consider instead.
1. All-White Kitchens
Why Agents Say Avoid It: The stark, all-white kitchen—white cabinets, white counters, white backsplash—once ruled as the epitome of modern elegance. But in 2025, agents report it’s losing steam. Buyers now crave warmth and personality, and all-white feels cold, sterile, and dated. “It’s been overdone,” says a seasoned agent from California. “Buyers walk in and see a blank slate that lacks character.”
The Downside: Beyond aesthetics, all-white kitchens show every spill and smudge, making them high-maintenance—a turn-off for busy families. They also lack the cozy vibe buyers seek in today’s market.
How It Hurts Value: A 2024 survey suggested homes with all-white kitchens sold 5-10% slower than those with mixed tones, as buyers factored in repaint costs.
What to Do Instead:
Warm Neutrals: Opt for greige, taupe, or soft beige cabinets paired with wood accents.
Color Pops: Add a sage green island or terracotta backsplash for depth.
Example: Swap white quartz counters for a honed beige stone with subtle veining—costing $40-$60 per square foot versus $50-$80 for white quartz—and pair with oak shelves.
Pro Tip: Test paint swatches under your lighting—white can look harsh under LEDs.
All-white kitchens are fading fast. Agents say they’re a relic of the 2010s—skip them for a warmer, more inviting space.
2. Open Shelving Overload
Why Agents Say Avoid It: Open shelving had its moment as a chic, airy alternative to upper cabinets. But agents warn it’s a gamble in 2025. “Buyers love the look until they realize it’s impractical,” notes a Pennsylvania agent. Dust, grease, and clutter make it a maintenance nightmare.
The Downside: Open shelves expose dishes and pantry items, which can look messy to buyers expecting a tidy, move-in-ready home. They also reduce storage—a dealbreaker for small kitchens.
How It Hurts Value: Homes with excessive open shelving often sit longer on the market, as buyers mentally tally the cost of adding cabinets ($1,000-$3,000).
What to Do Instead:
Hybrid Approach: Use one open shelf for decor, paired with closed cabinets for function.
Glass-Front Cabinets: Show off curated items while hiding chaos—$50-$100 per door at hardware stores.
Example: Replace a full wall of shelves with two shaker-style cabinets ($200 total) and a single oak shelf ($20).
Pro Tip: Style shelves minimally—three items max—to avoid a cluttered vibe.
Open shelving overload is out. Agents say buyers want practicality over Pinterest perfection in 2025.
3. Granite Countertops
Why Agents Say Avoid It: Granite was the gold standard for decades, but agents now call it passé. “It screams early 2000s,” says an Illinois agent. Buyers prefer quartz, concrete, or butcher block for a fresher, less predictable look.
The Downside: Speckled granite patterns date a kitchen fast, and its porous nature requires yearly sealing—extra upkeep buyers don’t want.
How It Hurts Value: Granite can shave 3-5% off offers in competitive markets, as buyers budget $2,000-$4,000 to swap it out.What to Do Instead:
Quartz: Durable, low-maintenance, and available in bold hues ($50-$80/sq.ft.).
Wood: Warm butcher block ($30-$50/sq.ft.) adds organic charm.
Example: Install a matte gray quartz counter for $1,500 (30 sq.ft.) instead of $2,000 for granite.
Pro Tip: If you’re stuck with granite, refinish it with a concrete overlay kit ($100) for a modern twist.
Granite’s reign is over. Agents say it’s a red flag for dated design—opt for alternatives that pop.
4. Over-the-Range Microwaves
Why Agents Say Avoid It: Microwaves above the stove save space, but agents note they’re falling out of favor. “They clutter the sightline and feel cheap,” says a Minnesota agent. Buyers prefer integrated appliances in 2025.
The Downside: They limit ventilation options (hoods are trendier) and can make a kitchen feel cramped. Plus, they’re a hassle for shorter folks to reach.
How It Hurts Value: Buyers deduct $200-$500 mentally for removal and vent upgrades.
What to Do Instead:
Drawer Microwaves: Sleek and ergonomic, built into an island ($800-$1,200).
Countertop Swap: Move it to a shelf or pantry ($100-$300 for a new spot).
Example: Ditch the $150 over-range unit for a $900 drawer microwave—pricey but resale-friendly.
Pro Tip: Pair with a slim hood ($200) for better airflow and style.
Over-the-range microwaves are out. Agents say they’re a functional relic—go for seamless integration instead.
5. Farmhouse Overkill
Why Agents Say Avoid It: The modern farmhouse look—shiplap, barn doors, apron sinks—peaked years ago. “It’s too specific,” says a Florida agent. “Buyers in urban or suburban homes find it out of place.”
The Downside: Over-the-top rustic vibes alienate buyers who don’t live the country life. It’s also costly to undo—shiplap removal runs $500-$1,000.
How It Hurts Value: Farmhouse-heavy kitchens can drop offers by 5%, as buyers see a full redo ahead.
What to Do Instead:
Transitional Style: Blend rustic (wood accents) with modern (clean lines).
Subtle Nods: Keep one element—like a sink—but skip the barn doors.
Example: Paint over $300 shiplap walls for $50 and swap a $200 barn door for a pocket door ($150).
Pro Tip: Use peel-and-stick wood planks ($30/roll) for a reversible rustic touch.
Farmhouse overkill is fading. Agents say tone it down for broader appeal in 2025.
6. Cherry Wood Cabinets
Why Agents Say Avoid It: Cherry-stained cabinets, with their reddish hue, feel stuck in the ‘90s. “They darken a space and look old-fashioned,” says a California agent. Buyers prefer lighter, natural woods or painted finishes.
The Downside: The heavy tone shrinks small kitchens visually, and refinishing costs $1,000-$2,000.
How It Hurts Value: Cherry cabinets can deter offers, dropping value 3-7% as buyers plan a gut job.
What to Do Instead:
Paint Over: Use a light gray or white ($50 in supplies) to refresh them.
Natural Woods: Swap for oak or walnut ($1,500-$3,000 for a small kitchen).
Example: Paint cherry cabinets white for $60 instead of $2,000 for new ones.
Pro Tip: Sand lightly and prime twice for a smooth finish—cherry bleeds through easily.
Cherry wood is a no-go. Agents say it’s a dated eyesore—lighten up for a modern edge.
7. Closed-Off Layouts
Why Agents Say Avoid It: Separate, walled-off kitchens are losing ground to open plans. “Buyers want flow,” says a Pennsylvania agent. “Closed kitchens feel isolating and small.”
The Downside: They limit social interaction—a key selling point—and make spaces feel dated versus airy, modern designs.
How It Hurts Value: Closed kitchens can cut offers by 5-10%, as buyers budget $5,000-$15,000 to knock down walls.
What to Do Instead:
Partial Openness: Remove a half-wall or add a pass-through ($500-$1,000).
Island Focus: Add a multi-use island ($1,000-$2,000) to bridge spaces.
Example: Open a 10x10 kitchen with a $700 half-wall removal instead of a $10,000 full reno.
Pro Tip: Check for load-bearing walls first—hire a pro ($100-$200) to assess.
Closed-off kitchens are out. Agents say buyers crave connection—open it up where you can.
8. Frosted Glass Lighting
Why Agents Say Avoid It: Frosted or shaded fixtures, popular in the ‘80s and ‘90s, dim kitchens and feel busy. “They make everything look dated,” says a Minnesota agent. Buyers want bright, open vibes.
The Downside: Dim lighting hides a kitchen’s potential, and frosted designs clash with 2025’s sleek trends.
How It Hurts Value: Buyers deduct $100-$300 to swap fixtures, nudging offers down slightly.
What to Do Instead:
Clear Glass: Use pendants or sconces with exposed bulbs ($20-$50 each).
LED Strips: Add under-cabinet lighting ($30-$60) for a modern glow.
Example: Replace a $50 frosted chandelier with two $30 clear pendants—total: $60.
Pro Tip: Opt for warm LEDs (2700K) to keep the space cozy, not clinical.
Frosted glass lighting is passé. Agents say brighten it up for a fresh, buyer-friendly look.
9. Overly Bold Backsplashes
Why Agents Say Avoid It: Wildly colorful or intricate backsplashes (think bright mosaics or loud patterns) can polarize buyers. “It’s too personal,” says an Illinois agent. “What you love, they might hate.”
The Downside: Buyers see a $1,000-$2,000 replacement cost, and bold designs clash with neutral trends gaining traction in 2025.
How It Hurts Value:A niche backsplash can slow sales by weeks, dropping offers 3-5%.
What to Do Instead:
Subtle Patterns: Use herringbone or subway tiles in muted tones ($2-$5/sq.ft.).
Neutral Pop: Try a soft green or gray zellige tile ($8-$12/sq.ft.).
Example: Swap a $300 neon mosaic for $100 in white subway tiles (20 sq.ft.).
Pro Tip: Paint over a bold backsplash with tile paint ($20) if removal isn’t an option.
Overly bold backsplashes are risky. Agents say keep it simple to appeal to the masses.
Conclusion
Kitchens can make or break a home sale, and in 2025, real estate agents are clear: some trends are more liability than asset. Avoiding all-white kitchens, open shelving overload, granite countertops, and the other pitfalls on this list ensures your space stays marketable and timeless. These trends—once celebrated—now signal dated design or impracticality to buyers, potentially lowering offers or stalling sales. Instead, lean into warm neutrals, functional storage, and subtle modern touches that balance style with broad appeal. You don’t need a fortune to sidestep these missteps—painting cabinets, swapping fixtures, or tweaking layouts can cost under $100 each yet yield a kitchen buyers love. Whether you’re staying put or listing soon, heed agent advice: skip the fads, play it smart, and craft a kitchen that stands the test of time. Your home’s value—and your peace of mind—will thank you.
10 FAQs
Why are all-white kitchens a problem in 2025?
They feel cold and outdated to buyers, who now prefer warmer, personalized spaces. Maintenance is also a hassle, lowering appeal.
Can I keep some open shelving without hurting value?
Yes, but limit it—one shelf for decor paired with cabinets works. Too much looks cluttered and impractical.
Is granite really that bad for resale?
It’s not a dealbreaker, but agents say it dates a kitchen. Quartz or wood are fresher, buyer-friendly options.
What’s wrong with over-the-range microwaves?
They disrupt sightlines, limit ventilation, and feel cheap. Buyers prefer integrated or hidden appliances in 2025.
How do I tone down a farmhouse kitchen affordably?
Paint shiplap, swap barn doors for sleek ones, and keep just one rustic element—like a sink—for under $200.
Can I salvage cherry cabinets without replacing them?
Yes—paint them a light color ($50-$100) or sand and stain to a natural tone to modernize affordably.
Why do buyers hate closed-off kitchens?
They want open, social spaces. Closed layouts feel small and isolating, often requiring costly updates.
Are frosted lights worth keeping?
No—they dim the space and look old. Swap for clear glass or LEDs ($20-$50) to brighten and update.
What makes a backsplash too bold?
Bright colors or busy patterns are too niche—buyers prefer neutral, timeless designs they won’t need to rip out.
How do I avoid these trends on a tight budget?
Focus on paint ($20-$50), hardware swaps ($15-$30), and small tweaks like lighting or decor—big impact, low cost.
Comments